gamedragon148388's honest review, “The Era of ‘AI Clicks’”: If It Cannot Be Avoided, Face It: Cryptography and Security to Protect Systems course
Reviews 2
Average rating 3
A course that feels like it was simply generated by AI, reviewed by AI, and even has AI-written replies to reviews. Strange metaphors that are extremely distracting are used repeatedly throughout the course, and the overall context feels very unpolished. I feel like you could get something similar by just looking at the table of contents and asking GPT to explain it to you. I knew that some of this instructor’s courses were mass-produced with AI, and I still bought them because the content was necessary and I was willing to overlook that. But this one feels like it goes too far.
1
Hello, KeepGoing. First of all, I’m sorry that after you invested your valuable time and money in taking the course, I made you feel that the analogies were excessive or that the flow and context of the explanations had not been sufficiently refined. As I was trying to explain the subject of cryptography as simply as possible, with less mathematical content, I used many real-world analogies. During the process of creating and reviewing the material, I also had many conversations with various tools, including AI. If that process resulted in the analogies becoming excessive or some expressions not being polished enough, I certainly believe that is something I need to improve. However, as the person who created the course, I honestly felt quite disheartened by the comments that it seemed like a lecture simply produced by AI, or that asking GPT to explain it after looking only at the table of contents would result in something similar. I am also fully aware that AI is far superior to me. The good models available today are so capable—in terms of both the amount of knowledge they possess and their ability to explain—that it is difficult to compare them with me as an individual. I actively use them in my own studies and while creating lectures as well. That is precisely why I do not believe the role of a lecture is simply to explain knowledge. I believe the role of a lecture is to organize everything into one coherent flow: where to begin, how much you need to know, what is important and what can be skipped at the current stage, whether what you have understood is actually correct, and, in actual development, which option to use and in what situation among the various available choices. I think cryptography, in particular, is a field in which concepts are scattered across separate pieces. AI is very good at explaining concepts such as hashes, symmetric keys, public keys, certificates, digital signatures, key exchange, and HTTPS individually. However, connecting why these concepts are necessary, how they relate to one another, what should be learned next after understanding one concept, and how they ultimately work together within a real system is a different matter. That connection and judgment are what I wanted to include in the course. When you ask the same question to multiple AI models, they often provide different explanations and feedback. At times like that, you ultimately have to decide which explanation to accept, what to filter out, and how far to study. I believe the role of someone creating a lecture is to organize and make those judgments on your behalf, based on their own experience of studying, using, and making mistakes along the way. That is probably why the single statement that it was all made by AI felt even more disheartening. I do not want to hide the fact that I used AI, nor am I trying to claim that I am better than AI. Quite the opposite—AI is already extraordinarily capable. However, while making use of good tools, I do not believe AI takes care of everything, including deciding what to include and leave out, what order to explain things in, how to connect concepts that are scattered apart, and whether the content is actually correct all the way through. If the meaning of a course created by a person disappears simply because the same questions can be asked of AI, then that seems to lead to a fundamental question: Is there any reason to take a course created by a person in almost any field anymore? On the contrary, I believe that in an age when AI provides us with an overwhelming number of answers, the role of organizing what to learn, which answers to trust, and how to connect that knowledge has become even more important. I see that you have currently completed about 29% of the course. If possible, I would appreciate it if you could continue a little further and consider the overall flow of the course as well. As the course progresses, it covers a variety of topics, from directly implementing how HTTPS works to elliptic-curve cryptography, which is widely used in modern cryptographic systems. Above all, I believe that if you look at how I tried to connect cryptographic concepts that may appear to exist separately, arranging them in a particular order and explaining how they fit together within a single system, you may get a better sense of what I wanted to convey in creating this course. Even after completing the course, if you still feel that it was ultimately not much different from putting the table of contents into GPT and studying from its explanations, I will humbly accept that evaluation as well. Once again, I’m sorry that your experience with the course so far has been disappointing. I will not take your comments about the density of the analogies, the flow of the explanations, or expressions that were not sufficiently refined lightly. I will reflect on them as I work to improve the course going forward. That said, I hope this course will not be seen merely as a result produced by AI. From the creator’s perspective, it felt a little heavy-hearted to think that, in that one sentence, all the time I spent considering, choosing, and verifying things while creating this course seemed to disappear. Thank you for leaving your review.
0

