ckdduf10216446's honest review, “The Era of ‘AI Clicks’”: If It Cannot Be Avoided, Face It: Cryptography and Security to Protect Systems course
Reviews 1
Average rating 1
I think the quality of the lectures is unacceptable. It seems like you just took NotebookLM videos and used them as-is. You explain everything using the weird metaphors typical of AI, and the lecture notes meant to supplement them feel like nothing more than summaries of the AI videos. I was so taken aback while listening that I’m writing a review for the first time. You’d be much better off studying by chatting with an AI service you already have. ++) Hello, as you suggested, I wanted to write another review after finishing the entire course. My opinion hasn’t changed even after completing it. Thank you.
1
Hello, Donggeurami. First of all, I sincerely apologize that you experienced such great disappointment and discomfort with the delivery style and analogies while taking the course. I am taking your candid and incisive criticism very seriously. As you pointed out, we live in an era when anyone can ask about and learn technical knowledge through excellent AI tools. I also used various AI tools as supplementary aids while preparing this course. However, this course is not a video that simply reproduces or summarizes answers generated by AI. I planned and designed every slide myself, personally handled everything down to the smallest editing cut, and reviewed the script countless times. In particular, cryptography itself has a very high barrier to entry because it involves intertwined mathematical principles and abstract concepts. I repeatedly considered how to make these difficult mechanisms take root most intuitively in learners’ minds, and the analogies and examples in the course were carefully selected and refined through that process. Nevertheless, if that intention was not fully conveyed and instead came across as artificial or awkward, it was because I was not sufficiently thoughtful in my delivery. I deeply reflect on this and will continue improving the lecture notes and supplementary materials based on the feedback you provided. The essence of this course, as I see it, is not 'a list of fragmentary pieces of knowledge,' but rather providing the context and criteria for 'how different pieces of knowledge connect to systems and real-world practice.' I devoted the most time and energy to establishing the framework of the curriculum: determining the order in which the scattered concepts of cryptography should be connected so that learners can develop a solid design perspective without unnecessary trial and error. I see that you have currently completed approximately 24% of the course. Although the analogies and delivery style in the introductory conceptual sections may have caused you fatigue, I cautiously ask that you look a little more closely at the technical cause-and-effect relationships and design intentions behind the presentation, setting aside the way they were expressed for a moment. As the course progresses, the concepts covered earlier are organically integrated into the context of real-world systems, allowing the original intent of the curriculum to become clear. If you complete the course, I am confident that it will provide substantial practical help in grasping the underlying structure of the technology without getting lost amid the overwhelming amount of information. If there are any analogies that seem unclear or technical concepts that you find difficult to accept while taking the course, please feel free to leave a question at any time. I will personally take responsibility for answering it thoroughly, using the clearest and most practical language possible. Thank you once again for your valuable feedback.
0

